Pursuant to Rule 45 of the Ohio Rules of Juvenile Procedure, Chapters 2151 and
2152 of the Ohio Revised Code, and Rule 5 of the Rules of Superintendence for
Courts of Ohio, the following rules are hereby adopted by the Juvenile Division
of the Lucas County Court of Common Pleas, effective August 1, 2004 and entered
upon the Journal of the Court.
These rules supersede any other previously adopted rules and the same are
hereby repealed.
Juvenile Rule 1
COURT AND ATTORNEY DECORUM
Proper decorum in the Court is necessary to the administration of the Court’s
business.
1.1 No radio or television transmission, voice recording device (other than the
court’s audio recording of the proceedings) or the making or taking of pictures
shall be permitted without prior judicial approval.
1.2 Spectators shall not be allowed in the courtroom without the consent of the
presiding Judge or Magistrate. No child shall be permitted to enter or remain
in any courtroom unless accompanied by an adult. In every case of an adult
charged with a criminal offense, the right of public trial and hearing shall be
observed, with the right to trial by jury as provided by law or the Rules of
Criminal Procedure.
1.3 Food and beverages are prohibited in the courtroom during all hearings.
Smoking is prohibited throughout the building at all times.
1.4 Persons committing any violation of proper conduct shall be removed from the
courtroom or the waiting room area by security personnel charged with
enforcement of this rule.
1.5 Counsel for all parties shall be present and before the Court at the
assigned hearing time.
1.6 If counsel is not present in court at the assigned hearing time, the case
may commence without counsel, may be continued, or dismissed, as determined by
the presiding Judge or Magistrate.
1.7 When counsel is going to be late for hearing, counsel must make a reasonable
effort to notify the presiding Judge or Magistrate as soon as is practical to
explain the reason for his/her tardiness.
1.8 Repeated lateness or absences may result in the removal of counsel from the
appointment of cases in the Lucas County Juvenile Court.
1.9 Upon entering courtrooms, persons must discontinue all cell phone use and
cell phones are to be turned off until exiting the courtroom.
Juvenile Rule 2
SESSIONS OF COURT
2.1 The Juvenile Court shall be open for the transaction of business from 8:30
a.m. - 4:30 p.m., on all business days, Monday through Friday, with legal
holidays as provided by law to be observed. The Juvenile Court, at the
discretion of and upon the order of the Administrative Judge, may be open at
other hours for matters of extraordinary nature or importance.
2.2 The Court shall sit in session between the hours of 8:30 a.m. - 12:00 noon
and 1:00 p.m. - 4:30 p.m. At the discretion of the Judges or Magistrates,
hearings may be scheduled at other times.
Juvenile Rule 3
COURT RECORDS/RECORDINGS
3.1 Probation Reports. Probation reports and records of the probation department
shall be considered confidential information and shall not be made public. The
inspection of Court Records by attorneys and other interested parties shall be
governed by Rule 32 (C) of the Ohio Rules of Juvenile Procedure. No person
shall be permitted to read Court records unless proper authorization is given
by the presiding Judge or Magistrate.
3.2 Maintenance of Official Cases. The records of official cases shall be
maintained as provided by law (ORC 2151.18 and Sup. R 26) and as provided by
local rules of this Court.
3.3 Who may Inspect Court Records. Records of cases involving juveniles shall be
open for inspection by the parent(s), custodian(s), guardian(s), and
attorney(s) of record, of any child affected by any order of the proceeding.
Otherwise, such records shall not be available to any person except by order of
the presiding Judge, Magistrate or by legal process from a court of competent
jurisdiction.
3.4 Adult Cases. The records of adult cases shall be public records as provided
by law, and the same shall be maintained in a separate appearance docket for
such cases.
3.5 Official Cases. All official matters filed in the Juvenile Division shall be
assigned a case number.
3.6 Unofficial Cases. Unofficial cases considered by the Court staff shall not
be subject to the provisions of the foregoing rules; and no person shall have
access to such cases without an order of the Judge.
3.7 Records of Proceedings. Pursuant to Juv. R. 37, a complete record of all
testimony, or other oral proceedings shall be taken in shorthand, stenotype or
by any other adequate mechanical or electronic recording device.
3.8 No public use shall be made by any person, including a party, of any record
or transcript thereof except in the course of an appeal or as authorized by the
Court.
3.9 If a request for a transcript is for purposes of an appeal, the court
reporter will certify the Docketing Statement by indicating an estimated number
of pages and how much time is needed to complete the transcript. In indigent
cases, the transcript is prepared and the Court is billed. In non-indigent
cases, the attorney will be advised by the court reporter of the estimated cost
of the transcript and a deposit is required prior to the preparation of the
transcript.
3.10 If a request for transcript is for cases that are pending further hearing,
(i.e., objections, trial, closed cases, etc.) that request must be made by
filing a written Motion whether the attorney is appointed, or retained, or
represents the State. The Motion should specify who is responsible for payment.
No transcript shall be prepared unless ordered by the Court. The same rules
apply as in appeal cases: in indigent cases, the transcript is prepared and the
Court is billed; in non-indigent cases, a deposit is required prior to
preparation of the transcript.
3.11 The policy of this Court is that indigent parties shall have access to
transcripts/recordings equal to that of non-indigent parties. The officer of
the Court, charged with securing counsel for indigent parties, shall determine
those individuals entitled to a free or reduced rate transcript. All
transcripts fully or partially paid by the Court must be approved by Judge’s
order.
3.12 Requests by attorneys of record to listen to audio recordings must be
approved by the presiding Judge. Notice must be given by requesting party to
all other parties and attorneys of record with the understanding that audio
recordings may include what is considered “off the record” communications and
statements by the attorneys and clients.
Juvenile Rule 4
PROCEDURES - JUVENILES
4.1 The Court hereby expresses the policy that the deputy clerks of the Juvenile
Division shall not prepare juvenile complaints unless instructed to do so by
the Judge. The Court shall not be placed in the position of initiating
complaints by its staff and thereby promoting the conclusion that cases are
being started by the Court, and thereby casting the Court in a non-judicial
character. This rule does not apply to the filing of motions by the Probation
or Intake departments for violation of terms of probation or court orders.
4.2 The Court may require the execution of forms as it shall prescribe to be
filed with any pleading or Motion filed with the Clerk. No pleading or motion
shall be accepted for filing until the information requested in such forms
shall be provided, unless waived by presiding Judge or Magistrate.
4.3 Attorneys requesting interim orders shall prepare and submit proposed orders
with their motion.
4.4 Consent judgment entries shall be prepared by counsel as directed by the
Court, other than in delinquency cases, and shall be filed within thirty (30)
days after the hearing, or as otherwise ordered/allowed by the presiding Judge
or Magistrate.
4.5 Pursuant to O. Juv. R. 16(A) service by publication shall be made by posting
and mailing. Upon the filing of an affidavit, the clerk shall cause service of
notice to be made by posting in Lucas County Court of Common Pleas, Juvenile
Division; Lucas County Court of Common Pleas, Domestic Relations Division;
Lucas County Court of Common Pleas, General Division; Lucas County Children
Services; and the Lucas County Corrections Center.
The notice shall be posted in the required locations in conspicuous place and
manner for seven (7) consecutive days prior to the date of the hearing. The
clerk shall also cause the summons and pleadings to be mailed by ordinary mail,
address correction requested, to the last known address of the party to be
served, and obtain a certificate of mailing from the United States Postal
Service.
Juvenile Rule 5
PROCEDURE - ADULTS
5.1 The statutory procedures and the Rules of Criminal Procedure shall be
followed with respect to adult criminal actions within the jurisdiction of the
Juvenile Division.
5.2 All persons charged with offenses who are being held under process from this
Court or who have been arrested and charged in this Court shall be brought
before the Court for an arraignment or bond hearing immediately upon arrest or
the next session of Court. If permitted, defendants may post bond in accordance
with Ohio Rules of Criminal Procedure.
5.3 In cases in which the defendants have a right to a trial by jury, the
defendant or his counsel shall demand a trial by jury no less than ten (10)
days prior to the date assigned for trial. Failure to notify the Court either
in person or in writing may be deemed just cause for entering a continuance
without the consent of the defendant, or the Court may order the matter to
proceed to trial before the Court without a jury.
Juvenile Rule 6
RIGHT TO COUNSEL, COURT APPOINTED COUNSEL, COURT PERSONNEL AND ATTORNEYS
6.1 The right of all parties to be represented and to retain counsel of their
own choosing is implicit in the law and is fully recognized by this Court. Upon
request, indigent parties shall be appointed counsel as provided in the Ohio
Revised Code and Ohio Rules of Juvenile Procedure.
6.2 The Court shall maintain a list of attorneys approved by the Administrative
Judge for appointment to indigent parties or to serve as guardian ad litem.
Attorneys on the appointment list shall complete six hours of CLE, specific to
juvenile law, each calendar year and provide documentation of the same by
December 31 of each year to the Court.
6.3 Court employees shall maintain a neutral and impartial position and shall
not function as advocates or adversaries. Court personnel shall not indicate
that counsel is or is not necessary in any particular case. When there is an
attorney of record, court personnel shall make all contact with the client
through the attorney.
6.4 No attorney of record will be allowed to withdraw nor may he/she be
discharged within fourteen (14) days of the trial date except for good cause
shown and provided that such action is not the fault of the attorney and is not
for the purpose of delay.
Juvenile Rule 7
BONDS/RECOGNIZANCE
7.1 Appearance bonds for adults and/or juveniles shall be fixed by the Judge or
Magistrate in each individual case upon arraignment, or at such other time as
may be determined; and the deputy clerks shall endorse on all adult warrants
the amount of bond as may be provided by the judge for such offense. The
issuance of a warrant without endorsement as to the amount of bond shall
indicate that the bond must be fixed by the presiding Judge or Magistrate.
7.2 Other bonds or recognizance to appear as may be provided by the Judge or
Magistrate shall be in the form as provided by the law, order of this Court or
other Court to which the person may be held to answer. Responsibility of
parents for appearances of juveniles shall be considered on the same basis as
bonds.
7.3 The sufficiency of sureties shall be determined by the presiding Judge
or assigned Magistrate in each case; and when real property is offered as
security by a surety, the Court shall require twice the value of the property
as it appears upon the county tax list maintained by the office of the County
Auditor.
Juvenile Rule 8
CONTINUANCES
8.1 Motions for continuances shall be made in accordance with the Rules of
Superintendence for the Courts of Ohio (Sup. R. 41), effective July 1, 1997.
8.2 All applications for continuances or advancements shall be made to the
presiding Judge or Magistrate by written Motion and, except as hereinafter
provided, such application must be made seven (7) days before the day of trial
or hearing and after notice to opposing counsel and the Guardian ad Litem. No
case will be continued on the day of trial or hearing except for good cause
shown. The cause shown must include that it was not known to counsel prior to
the day of trial and that counsel has used diligence to be ready for trial.
Counsel must have notified, or made diligent effort to notify, all parties as
soon as he/she became aware of the necessity to ask for a postponement. This
rule cannot be waived by consent of counsel. Cases will be continued when
counsel is actually engaged in trial in another court provided such counsel
notifies the Judge or Magistrate of being so engaged.
8.3 The clerk’s office shall have available a pre-printed Motion for
Continuance form for use by counsel or pro se parties. Upon the filing of a
Motion for Continuance, the clerk or designated employee shall take the Motion
to the presiding Judge or Magistrate.
8.4 All requests for continuances, whether written or oral, shall be ruled
upon and noted on the case docket sheet by the presiding Judge or Magistrate
within 48 hours of presentation to the Court. The docket entry shall contain
the date, party making the request and whether the continuance is granted or
denied.
Juvenile Rule 9
PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCES
9.1 Unless otherwise ordered, the pre-trial conference shall not be assigned later than two (2) weeks before the assigned date of the trial of the action.
9.2 Unless otherwise ordered, trial counsel shall appear at pre-trial conferences with their clients, unless their clients appearance has been waived by the presiding Judge or Magistrate. At the pre-trial, counsel should be prepared for settlement of all issues. In the event that all issues are not settled at the pre-trial, counsel shall be fully prepared to discuss all the issues set out below at pre-trial:
(a) Those matters set forth in Rule 16 of the Civil Rules.
(b) Further discovery proceedings including a completion date.
©) Trial briefs.
(d) Identification of witnesses and disclosure of their statements and potential testimony.
(e) Views of scene.
(f) Status of case for trial.
(g) Narrowing trial issues by stipulation.
(h) Other than in delinquency cases, parties shall have made at least one (1) good faith attempt to settle the case.
9.3 Failure of an attorney to be prepared for pre-trial conference may result in the imposition of
sanctions, attorney fees and/or court costs.
Juvenile Rule 10
DRUG COURT
10.1 Pursuant to Evidence Rule 408, statements made in Drug Court hearings shall
be treated as evidence of conduct or statements made in compromise negotiations
and are not admissible to prove the underlying cause of action.
10.2 Pursuant to Evidence Rule 410, statements made in Drug Court hearings
will be treated as participation in plea discussions, and will not be
admissible to prove the underlying cause of action.
10.3 This rule does not limit the admissibility of evidence provable by
independent, extrinsic evidence.
Juvenile Rule 11
MEDIATION CONFERENCES
11.1 All complaints or motions for the allocation of parental rights and
responsibilities or visitation and companionship filed subsequent to a
determination of parentage, with the exception of those approved by a Judge or
Magistrate, cases involving domestic violence or child abuse, or a party living
outside the jurisdiction of the Court, will be referred for pre-trial mediation
conference upon filing. Filings not referred for pre-trial mediation are
referred to a Judge or Magistrate.
11.2 If the parties reach an agreement in a mediation conference, and the
agreement is filed as a mediation report pursuant to ORC 3109.052, the Court
shall consider the mediation report when it allocates parental rights and
responsibilities. The Court, however, will not be bound by the mediation report
and shall also consider factors listed in ORC 3109.04(F)(1) and the best
interest of the child(ren) when allocating parental rights and responsibilities
or visitation.
11.3 Attorneys of record on cases that reach an agreement in mediation but
who did not attend the mediation with their client will be mailed a letter with
a copy of the mediation agreement that their client has signed. If the attorney
does not approve the mediation agreement, the attorney must file a written
objection within ten (10) days from the date of the letter. If an objection is
timely filed, the case will be referred to the magistrate of record for
hearing. If no objection is timely filed, the mediation agreement will be sent
to the Judge for approval and journalized as a judgment entry in the case.
11.4 Procedures for screening parental rights cases where domestic violence
or child abuse has been identified are as follows:
A) Upon filing, Mediation shall screen the complaint or motion for domestic
violence or child abuse, or other acts of violence between the parties. If
violence or abuse is identified or alleged in that filing, the case is referred
to a hearing docket.
B) The presiding Judge or Magistrate when referring a case back to Mediation
where domestic violence or child abuse has been identified shall provide the
following in their referral order:
1) Where a civil protection order or restraining order is in effect between
the parties, or allegations of domestic violence or child abuse have been made,
the referral order shall list all issues to be addressed, the names of those
expected to attend, and any parameters or conditions set out for the mediation.
2) Pursuant to ORC 3109.052, where a party has been convicted of domestic
violence or child abuse, the presiding Judge or Magistrate shall provide
findings of fact upon referring the case for mediation.
C) Upon bench referral under B(1) or B(2) above, the mediator shall have the
option of screening the parties further to assess the parties for mediation.
These options include either a written questionnaire or a personal interview,
or both. If safety remains an issue, the mediator may elect to indicate that
mediation is not recommended; or if the mediation has been undertaken, the
parties or the mediator may terminate at any time and indicate that no
agreement has been reached.
11.4 Unofficial, delinquency, unruly and contributing cases may be referred
for a mediation conference by the court’s Intake Officer.
11.5 A mediation conference may be court ordered during the pendency of any
Juvenile Court case. If the parties enter into an agreement, the agreement may,
after judicial review, become part of the court record and become an
enforceable court order.
11.6 If mediation is court ordered in a dependency, neglect and abuse case,
it is a docketed event mandating the appearance of all parties and their
counsel.
11.7 Statements made during mediation conferences are subject to ORC Chapter
2710, ORC 3109.052 and Evidence Rules 408 and 410.
11.8 The mediator shall not disclose the contents of the mediation, except
as agreed to by all parties and in accordance with applicable statutes and
rules governing mediation disclosures.
11.9 Filing fees for mediation shall be assessed by the Juvenile Court Clerk
on all complaints to establish or motions to modify allocation of parental
rights and responsibilities, as well as grandparent visitation cases. Unless
the case is voluntarily dismissed by the filing party prior to mediation being
commenced, the mediation filing fees are not refundable.
11.10 Assessment of Mediation Costs. On cases that are referred to Mediation
but were not initially assessed filing fees for mediation, the presiding Judge
or Magistrate when referring a matter to mediation may assess one or both
parties court costs for mediation services. In addition, if a matter is
referred for mediation for what becomes prolonged mediation sessions or on
cases with numerous parties and issues, the presiding Judge or Magistrate may
order a party or parties to pay additional court costs for mediation services.
11.11 Motions for Mediation. When parents have an existing shared parenting
plan that contains the standard clause to seek mediation to resolve disputes
that arise prior to filing a motion with the court, parties may file a “Motion
for Mediation Pursuant to a Shared Parenting Plan.” The filing party will be
assessed mediation filing fees only. If after attempting mediation the parties
fail to resolve their dispute, at the request of the filing party, the
Mediation Magistrate shall write an order converting the Motion for Mediation
to a Motion to Modify the Allocation of Parental Rights. Upon doing so, the
filing party shall be assessed filings fees for this motion, reduced by
mediation filing fees previously paid.
Juvenile Rule 12
DISCOVERY
12.1 “Open discovery” facilitates settlement and timely preparation of the
issues in controversy. Information, documents and material in the custody,
control or possession of one party that are discoverable under Rule 24 of the
Ohio Rules of Juvenile Procedure (or Rule 26 of the Ohio Rules of Civil
Procedure where applicable) are considered an “open file” for the purpose of
discovery by another party subject to the limitations/protection of Rule 24(B)
of Ohio Rules of Juvenile Procedure or Rule 26©) of Ohio Rules of Civil
Procedure. Discoverable items include, but are not limited to, police reports,
supplemental police reports, and a children services agency case file
(excluding the referral sources, third party investigation reports, foster
parent records, adoption records, attorney-client privileged information and
attorney work product). This broad discovery assists in arriving at the truth,
expedites the hearing process, and may reduce the adversarial nature of the
proceedings.
12.2 Discovery authorized by Juv. R. 24 or Civ. R. 26 shall proceed upon the
written request of one party to another without a prior court order. The party
from whom discovery is requested shall produce forthwith for inspection,
copying, or photographing, the discoverable items to the requesting party as
follows or as otherwise agreed by the parties or instructed by the Court:
(a) if the requested party is non-governmental and represented by counsel,
at the office of the attorney for the requesting party;
(b) in the Parentage/UIFSA/Child Support proceedings where the requested
party is the Lucas County Child Support Enforcement Agency - at the LCCSEA
Legal Department;
©) in Delinquency/Unruly/Traffic cases where the prosecutor is the requested
party, at the office of the Lucas County Prosecutor, Juvenile Division;
(d) in Dependency/Neglect/Abuse cases where Lucas County Children Services
is the requested party, at the LCCS Legal Department.
12.3 When the discoverable materials are documents, any party may comply
with a request for discovery by forthwith mailing accurate and legible copies
to the attorney of the requesting party.
12.4 If (a) discoverable item(s) is/are physical evidence or other evidence
that is not readily copied, then the item(s) shall forthwith be made available
to the requesting party for inspection, photographing or other copying.
12.5 Counsel is ultimately responsible for the production of the
discoverable material.
12.6 Parties shall have a continuing duty to disclose additional
discoverable information or material subsequent to compliance with the original
request for discovery without the need to file a new request for more current
information.
12.7 Copies of discovered materials shall not be given by counsel to a
party. Attorneys shall not re-release any documents that are shared with them
including, but not limited to, reports of the Guardian ad Litem, police reports
and all supplemental reports.
12.8 Counsel is responsible for marking all trial exhibits prior to
commencement of hearing.
Juvenile Rule 13
GUARDIAN AD LITEM
13.1 In all cases wherein a Guardian ad litem is appointed to represent the best
interest of a child, orders will issue allowing the Guardian ad litem to have
access to and make copies of records and reports, as provided herein.
A) Upon presentation of the order allowing access and such identification as
may be reasonably required by the person, agency or office from whom the
information is sought, the Guardian ad litem shall be allowed to review and
copy all records related to the medical, dental, psychiatric, psychological,
social or legal matters of the child.
B) The person, agency or office from which the information is sought will
not reveal referral sources except as provided in Revised Code Chapter 5101.
13.2 In all cases where a child is alleged to be abused, neglected or
dependent and where a dispositional hearing has been scheduled, orders will
issue allowing the Guardian ad litem to have access to and make copies of
records and reports, as provided herein.
A) Upon presentation of the order allowing access and such identification as
may be reasonably required by the person, agency or office from whom the
information is sought, the Guardian ad litem shall be allowed to review and
copy all psychological, social or legal matters of the parties.
B) The person, agency or office from whom the information is sought will not
reveal information which is controlled by 42 Code of Federal Regulation, Part
2; Revised Code Sections 2945.38, 2945.39 or 2945.40 (except court docket
entries or court journal entries) unless presented an order for compliance
therewith.
13.3 Any copies, summaries, abstracts or extracts of reports and records
which are obtained or created pursuant to this rule are not to be disclosed by
the Guardian ad litem nor are they subject to discovery except as provided by
further order.
13.4 In all cases where a Guardian ad litem is appointed to represent the
best interest of a child, the GAL shall submit the following reports to the
Court:
A) Following the appointment as Guardian ad litem (GAL) in a dependency,
neglect, abuse, delinquency, unruly, or private custody case, the GAL shall
file a written report with the Court prior to the first hearing unless
otherwise directed by the presiding Judge or Magistrate.
B) In all proceedings on motions for permanent custody, a written report by
the GAL shall be filed with the Court prior to the permanent custody pre-trial.
The GAL permanent custody report shall cover any time period(s) not previously
covered in a written GAL report.
C) The GAL shall submit written or oral reports/recommendations to the Court
at any time the Court directs.
D) Any written amendment to a GAL Report must be filed seven (7) days before
a hearing unless otherwise permitted by the presiding Judge or Magistrate, and
shall be provided to all counsel by the GAL.
Juvenile Rule 14
PSYCHOLOGICAL REPORTS
14.1 In any case in which the Court orders a psychological evaluation, the
report of the psychologist shall be submitted to the Court within sixty (60)
days from the Court’s order, or as directed by the presiding Judge or
Magistrate.
14.2 Upon request and for good cause shown, the presiding Judge or
Magistrate may order the parties to submit to physical, psychological or
psychiatric evaluation. The request must be timely made and the Court shall
afford the parties a reasonable opportunity to respond. When the Judge or
Magistrate orders that an evaluation be done, it shall determine the party to
be responsible for the payment of the charges for same. The presiding Judge or
Magistrate may apportion the charges for such evaluation between the parties
and may tax the charge as costs.
14.3 Failure of a party to cooperate with an evaluation ordered by the Court
may result in the application of sanctions, including the imposition of fines
and incarceration; payment of attorney fees; reimbursement for lost wages; and
payment of the charges of the evaluator. If the party bringing the action fails
to cooperate, judgment may be entered against him or the matter dismissed.
14.4 The presiding Judge or Magistrate may require that reports made
pursuant to orders issued under this rule be delivered directly to the Court
and may prescribe the manner in which any reports made under this rule will be
distributed. It may restrict the access of the parties to the reports. The
presiding Judge or Magistrate may also limit the number of copies to be made of
the report and may require that any copies be returned to the Court upon the
conclusion of the action. Excess copies may be destroyed when the original
reports are retained as a part of the Court file.
Juvenile Rule 15
EMERGENCY HEARINGS -
NOTICE
15.1 Requests by Public or Private Agencies. Emergency hearing requests may be
made by a public children services agency or private child placing agency:
A) In any case in which an emergency hearing is requested for removal of a
child from a placement alleged to be dangerous pursuant to ORC 2151.31, the
Court shall set a time for emergency hearing the next business day or no later
than seventy-two (72) hours from the request. It is the responsibility of the
attorney filing the Complaint and Motion to notify all necessary parties and
attorney(s) of record.
B) The children services agency shall file the Complaint and Motion for
Shelter Care within the time frames designated by the Court. If the Motion for
Shelter Care is not filed timely, it will not be heard until the following day.
On the next business day following the issuance of a telephone ex parte order,
the agency shall file either a Complaint or a Motion to Dismiss the telephone
ex parte order.
15.2 Requests by Private Attorneys. Emergency hearing requests may be made
by private attorneys:
A) Prior to filing the Complaint, the attorney shall first bring a sworn
Complaint and Motion for Emergency Hearing to a Judge or Magistrate. Upon
approval of the judicial officer, the Court shall set a time for the hearing
the next business day or no later than seventy-two (72) hours from the request.
B) It is the responsibility of the attorney filing the Complaint and Motion to notify all necessary parties and attorneys of record of the time of the hearing.
Juvenile Rule 16
FAX FILING 1
16.1 Authorization The Juvenile Clerk shall maintain an independent telephone
line and facsimile machine to allow members of the bar to file documents no
longer than 10 pages in length with the court, 24 hours a day, seven days a
week, by following this rule. The number of the fax machine is 419-213-6933.
16.2 Fax Copies Filing of documents subsequent to an original complaint and
not requiring a security deposit may be filed by fax copy with the Juvenile
Clerk. Exhibits, original complaints, pleadings pursuant to appeal, and filings
that have an associated filing fee will not be accepted for fax filing. In
accordance with Civ.R.5(E), any signature on the fax filing shall be considered
to be authentic. If it is established that any transmission was made without
authority, the court shall order the filing stricken. The date and time of
receipt of any faxed document shall be the date and time imprinted on the
document by the facsimile machine receiving the transmission. Although faxes
will be received 24 hours a day, seven days a week, any fax copy received by
the clerk after 4:30 p.m. on a regular business day or on a weekend or holiday
shall be considered filed on the next business day by the clerk. Receipt of fax
submission will be acknowledged by the Juvenile Clerk via fax communication to
the attorney identified on the cover page no later than the next business day.
Acknowledgment of receipt will indicate either acceptance of filing or reason
for nonacceptance, and identification of any copy costs that will be assessed
and instructions for payment of those copy costs.
16.3 Requirements Any fax copy filed shall conform to the civil and criminal
rules and shall be preceded in transmission by a cover page, which includes the
following information:
? Caption of the case
? Case number
? Assigned Judge
? Description of the document being filed
? Attorney name, address, Ohio Supreme Court registration number, telephone and
fax number
? Date and time of fax initiation
? Transmitting fax number
? Number of pages, including the cover page, being transmitted Any document
requiring a signature shall either contain the signature on the source document
at the time of fax transmission or be submitted without the signature but the
notation “/s/” followed by the name of the signing person where the signature
appears in the signed source document.
16.4 Fax Documents as Originals The faxed document shall be considered the
original. Additional originals of the documents shall not be filed with the
Juvenile Clerk. The sending party must maintain possession of the source
document and make them available for inspection by the court upon request.
16.5 Charges If courtroom or service copies are needed for processing, the
Juvenile Clerk may charge the standard page rate or $1.00 per page for all
necessary copies. Attorney checks, cashier’s checks, and cash are acceptable
methods of payment.
Juvenile Rule 17
CASE MANAGEMENT
17.1 Pursuant to Sup. R. 39, as amended through July 1, 2002, the Court hereby
establishes the following plan for the management of cases filed in this
division.
17.2 The purpose of the case management plan is to ensure the readiness of
cases for pre-trial and trial and to maintain and improve the timely
disposition of cases. The plan is to be utilized in conjunction with Ohio
Revised Code, the Rules of Juvenile Procedure, the Rules of Civil Procedure and
the Rules of Criminal Procedure, where applicable.
17.3 Time frames set forth in this plan are guidelines only; failure to
follow such time frames in individual cases shall not affect the Court’s
jurisdiction or be grounds for dismissal.
A) Juvenile Traffic Cases
1. Pre-trials shall be scheduled within fourteen (14) days of arraignment.
2. Trials shall be held within sixty (60) days of filing. Dispositions shall
be held within ninety (90) days of filing.
B) Delinquency and Unruly Cases
1. Detention hearings will be held within seventy-two (72) hours after
admission to JDC or on the next business day, whichever is earlier (ORC
2151.314).
2. When detention is continued after the initial hearing:
a. Adjudication hearing will be scheduled
I. Ten (10) days from the filing of the complaint, if the complaint was not
filed when the child entered detention (Juv. R. 29 (A)
ii. Ten (10) days from the date detention began, if the complaint was filed
on or before the detention date.
b. Relinquishment of jurisdiction hearings will be held not less than three
(3) days nor more than ten (10) days from the date of the detention hearing.
c. If the child admits the charges or is found delinquent at trial, the
Court may proceed to disposition or continue the matter for completion of a
social history and investigation; in such case, the disposition will be
scheduled two (2) weeks after adjudication.
d. Final disposition for a child in detention will be completed within
ninety (90) days of the child’s being taken into custody.
e. Continuances may be granted upon showing of good cause.
3. Child not in detention.
a. All felonies and runaways are official filings and are entered into the
system within two (2) days.
b. All other case types, within ten (10) days of the complaint having been
signed, it will be screened by the intake officer to determine:
I. If it should be officially filed, or
ii. If it should be referred to the Court’s Mediation Program or an
appropriate community agency;
c. Arraignment will be held within thirty (30) days after the complaint is
filed.
I. If the child admits, the Court will proceed to disposition or refer the
matter to probation for a social history and investigation, in which case,
disposition will be scheduled within four (4) weeks after adjudication.
ii. If the child denies, the matter will be set for pre-trial within thirty
(30) days.
d. In delinquency and traffic cases, upon the approval of the Judge or
Magistrate, counsel may waive the child’s appearance, waive any defects in
time, place, or manner of service, and enter a denial.
e. Trials will be held within thirty (30) days after the pre-trial.
f. Continuances may be granted upon showing of good cause; however,
continuances should be for no longer than the period necessary to resolve the
good cause.
C. Parentage Cases
1. Summons shall issue within seventy-two (72) hours of the complaint having
been filed and shall include a pre-trial date not later than 60 days from the
date the complaint was filed.
2. At Pre-trial
a. If the defendant admits, the Court may proceed immediately to a
determination of a support order.
b. If the allegations are denied, or the defendant fails to appear the Court
may
I. Immediately schedule genetic tests to begin within fourteen (14) days,
and
ii. Schedule the matter for trial.
3. If the genetic tests show
a. Exclusion, the Court will dismiss at the next scheduled hearing;
b. Inclusion, and
I. Defendant admits, the Court may proceed immediately to determination of
the support order; or if
ii. Defendant denies, the matter may proceed to trial that day or be
scheduled for hearing within thirty(30) days.
4. If service of summons is not made within one hundred and eighty (180)
days from the date of issuance, the complaint shall be dismissed without
prejudice on the court’s own motion.
5. Continuances may be granted upon showing of good cause.
D. Allocation of Parental Rights and Responsibilities and Third Party
Custody and Visitation Cases.
1. If appropriate, cases will be initially referred to the Court’s Mediation
program prior to being placed on a preliminary hearing docket.
2. Summons shall issue within three (3) business days of filing, giving
notice of preliminary hearing to be held within forty-five (45) days.
3. If matters are not resolved at the preliminary hearing, a trial will be
held within thirty (30) days.
4. All parental rights and third party custody and visitation complaints
will be resolved within one-hundred twenty (120) days of filing.
5. Continuances may be granted upon showing of good cause.
E. Dependency, Neglect and Abuse Cases
1. When a child is removed from his home pursuant to an ex parte order, a
hearing will be held the next business day or not later than seventy-two (72)
hours after the child is placed in shelter care (ORC 2151.314).
2. When a private agency files a request for permanent custody based upon a
permanent surrender, a hearing will be held within thirty (30) days of the
filing of the complaint.
3. The adjudicatory hearing will be held within thirty (30) days of the
filing of the complaint.
4. Disposition hearings shall be held within ninety (90) days of the filing
of the complaint.
5. Continuances may be granted upon showing of good cause.
Juvenile Rule 18
MAGISTRATES
18.1 The powers and duties of Magistrates shall be defined in Rule 40, Ohio
Rules of Juvenile Procedure (as amended July 1, 2001) ; Rule 53, Ohio Rules of
Civil Procedure (as amended July 1, 1998) ; and Rule 19, Ohio Rules of Criminal
Procedure, as amended July 1, 2000.
18.2 Magistrate Pre-Trial Orders A Magistrate may enter orders effective
without judicial approval in pre-trial proceedings. Any person may appeal to
the Court from an interlocutory order by filing a Motion to Set the Order
Aside, stating the party’s objection with particularity. The pendency of a
Motion to Set Aside does not stay the effectiveness of the Magistrate’s order
unless the Magistrate or the Judge grants a stay.
18.3 Magistrate Decisions A Magistrate is not required to prepare any report
other than the Magistrate’s Decision. After conducting the proceedings
necessary for decision of referred matters, the Magistrate shall prepare, sign,
and file a Magistrate Decision with the clerk. If any party requests findings
of fact and conclusions of law, the Magistrate Decision shall include findings
and conclusions. If an attorney of record requests findings of fact and
conclusions of law, he or she shall, if requested, present proposed findings
and conclusions to the Magistrate within seven (7) days of the request. Failure
to present proposed findings and conclusions within seven (7) days of the
request will be deemed withdrawal of the request.
18.4 Court’s Action on Magistrate Decisions The Magistrate Decision shall be
effective when adopted by the court as noted in the Journal record.
18.5 Objections to Magistrate Decisions Within fourteen (14) days of the
filing of a Magistrate Decision, a party may file written objections to the
decision. The objection shall be specific and state with particularity the
grounds for objection.
Juvenile Rule 19
PARENTING PLAN AND COMPANIONSHIP SCHEDULE
The Court shall adopt and cause to be published, an Interim Parenting
Schedule, a Parenting Plan and Companionship Schedule and a Long Distance
Parenting Plan and Companionship Schedule. Copies of each schedule shall be
made available through the office of the Clerk of the Juvenile Court.
Liberal parenting time is encouraged since contact with both parents is
important to a child(ren)’s well-being. The schedules are guidelines for
parenting time and it is the responsibility of the parties to adjust the
schedule to meet the best interest of their child(ren). The Court, or the
parties, may deviate from the schedule if it is in the best interest of the
child(ren).
Juvenile Rule 20
JUVENILE TRAFFIC VIOLATIONS BUREAU
20.1 Procedure
Pursuant to Ohio Traffic Rule 13.1, it is hereby created the Lucas
County Juvenile Traffic Violations Bureau, as part of the Juvenile Court
Clerk’s office. A person charged with being a Juvenile Traffic Offender by
reason of a violation which does not require a mandatory appearance pursuant to
this Rule may elect to proceed without a court appearance under the following
procedures:
A) The child must appear with his/her parent, guardian or custodian, at
the Juvenile Traffic Violations Bureau, Clerk’s Office, Lucas County Juvenile
Court, 1801 Spielbusch, Toledo, Ohio, 43624, during the regular hours of the
Court.
B) The child must enter an admission in writing to the offense charged
by signing the appropriate Admission and Waiver form available at the
Violations Bureau. The Admission form must also be signed as approved by the
parent, guardian or custodian.
C) The child or his/her parent, guardian or custodian MUST pay the
scheduled fine and court costs in the case. Should the child or his/her parent,
guardian or custodian not tender, in full, the fine and court costs imposed at
the time of the entry of admission, then the Bureau shall NOT accept the
admission and court appearance shall be required.
20.2 Mandatory Appearance Offenses
A) Any violation which involves an accident may not be processed through
the Traffic Violations Bureau, and a mandatory court appearances is required.
B) A second traffic violation of any kind which occurs prior to the age
of eighteen (18) years may not be processed through the Traffic Violations
Bureau, and a court appearance is required. If more than one moving traffic
violation is charged arising from a single incident or series of incidents,
none of those violations may be processed through the Traffic Violations
Bureau, and a court appearance is required.
C) The following offenses require formal court appearance and may not be
processed through the Juvenile Traffic Violations Bureau, although otherwise
permitted by these Rules:
1. Offenses which would be indictable if committed by an adult
2. Operating a motor vehicle while under the influence of alcohol or
drugs
3. Leaving the scene of an accident
4. Driving while under suspension or revocation of driver’s license
5. Driving without being licensed to drive
6. Failure to stop and remain standing upon meeting or overtaking a
school bus stopped on the highway for the purpose of receiving or discharging a
school child.
7. Drag racing
8. Reckless operation
9. Failure to maintain reasonable control
10. Speeding (in excess of 20 mph over posted limit)
11. Speeding in a school zone
12. Permitting unlicensed driver to operate a motor vehicle
13. Operating a motor vehicle under temporary instruction permit
unaccompanied by a licensed operator
14. Offenses charging a violation under Revised Code Chapter 29
15. Resisting/Interfering with an officer
16. Presenting false name or information to an officer
17. Any other offense or proceeding as determined by the Court
Juvenile Rule 21
CITATION OF RULES
These rules shall be known as the Rules of the Court of Common Pleas, Juvenile
Division, of Lucas County, Ohio, and may be cited as Lucas County Juvenile
Court Rules or L.C.J.C. Rules.